If you are like me, then from time to time, you have children—or even a spouse—who ask for pancakes. While I’m thankful it doesn’t lead to a situation like If You Give a Pig a Pancake, it still sparks some familiar questions: Do I want classic or fluffy? More ingredients or fewer? Regular or buttermilk?
For years, I wrestled with that dilemma. We don’t buy pancake mix, so every time I needed to make some from scratch, my mind would start scrambling. What recipe did I use last time? Was that the favorite or just another okay one?
Over time, I started narrowing down the options. I discovered that my family’s favorite pancakes were fluffy, a bit more complex in ingredients, and made with buttermilk. That helped—sort of. It still left a lot of recipes to sift through. Pun intended. 🙂

And then, there was the timing. If I got up and started mixing the batter, I had maybe 5–10 minutes before my “Kitchen Crew” showed up to help. Some would come in jabbering a mile a minute, eager to grab something—anything—and get to work. Others would stumble in, rubbing eyes and stifling yawns, but still determined to be part of the process. While not a problem, it did highlight another preference. Pancake batter that could be made ahead.
If I could mix up the batter the night before and only have to flip them the morning of, that would save a ton of time. Especially with the size of my family and their colossal appetites. A batch of pancakes that made 8-10 2″ pancakes just didn’t cut it.

So you can imagine my relief when I found a recipe that checked all the boxes. It made fluffy pancakes that were easy to mix up without skimping on the ingredients and called for buttermilk. It had yeast in it so it could be made ahead and put in the fridge overnight to fluff. And it even came with some bonuses. It wasn’t too sweet and it didn’t even have to be doubled. That’s what I call a winner!

It took all of one time to know we had finally found our favorite pancake recipe. This time, I ignored the voice that said I’d for sure remember which recipe we liked, and wrote it down on a recipe card. Not going to lose that one!
I wish I could remember where I originally found the recipe—I’m pretty sure it was Pinterest, but the exact source is lost to time. If you recognize it, let me know so I can give credit where it’s due!
INGREDIENTS
4 Cups Flour
1 Tablespoon Yeast*
1 Tablespoon Baking Powder
2 Tablespoons Sugar
2 Teaspoons Baking Soda
1 Teaspoon Salt
4 Eggs, Lightly Beaten
4 Cups Buttermilk
1/4 Cup Oil
INSTRUCTIONS
In a large bowl or the bowl of your stand mixer, whisk all the dry ingredients. Add wet ingredients and mix until just combined. Cover and refrigerate 8-24 hours. Stir before cooking.
Makes about 20-24 3″ pancakes.

*If you use active dry yeast, activate it in a 1/4 cup warm water or buttermilk and let sit for 5-10 minutes, while it blooms. If you use instant yeast, just follow the recipe as given.
So whether you’re flipping for a crowd or just need a little breakfast win, I hope this recipe brings as many smiles to your table as it has to ours. And if your Kitchen Crew shows up to help… pour them a little extra syrup for me.
Just don’t blame me if giving your kid a pancake leads to building a treehouse and finding a harmonica. 😉
















